This blog explores the contemporary political and cultural trends from a distinct perspective
War Crimes Again
Published on July 30, 2006 By Bahu Virupaksha In Politics
Early this morning around 12:30 Israeli F-16 jets dropped bombs on the southern Lebonese city of Qana. In this attack a building housing refugees who had fled from earlier Israeli bombardment were targetted and the men, women and children sleeping in the basement of the building were killed when the Israeli bombs demolished the building. The dispropotionate use of firepower by the Israelis is causing universal concern and while the world waits for the US to rein in the Israelis the pace of relentless killing continues without respite. Throughout the past 18 days Israeli jets have pounded hospitals,schools, appartment buildings, shopping centres, churches and civil infrastructure. They have replicated the pattern of destruction initiated in the GazaStrip--kill, attack civilians, destroy civic infrastructure and hospitals. In Lebanon the Israelis have gone one step beyond what they were doing in Gaza: they are follwing refugee convoys and killing them as they attempt to flee. This pattern of repraisals shows that the claim that Hizbollah is using civilians as cover for their rockets is false. Surely it is impossible to fire Katusha Rockets from refugee convoys.

The destruction rained upon Beirut city is so severe that parts of the city have been reduced to a moonscape with just rocks, glass and the stench of rotting flesh hanging like a hat overhead. The Isralis are not even allowing the Lebonese time to bury their dead. The pace of bombing is continuous and systematic. Using GPS and digital imaging the Israeli Air Force has been targetting the civilian areas killing in Southern Lebanon, Beirut ,Tyre and Qana over 600 civilians, the majority of whom are children and women. Helpless victims of a war state that has gone out of control. I wonder why the political leadership of Israel does not understand that for each of such crimes they commit, the chances of a lasting peace recedes. It is likely that Israel is not interested in peace and along with their big power supporter is taking the world for a ride when publically they endorse a two state solution and take every opportunity to kill, maim, and bomb innocent civilians who are not their enemy. The Internationall Commmunity has already began to feel that the UN ,like the League of Nations which could do little to control the Germans in the years before World War II,has become an embarrasment. Standing by watching helplessly as children and women are incenerated in the shelling and bombing unleashed by the State of Israel.

The International Community is aware that cluster munitions are being used by Israel against civilians. Howtizer fired cluster munitions are the most horrible and infernal engines of death from the death factories that supply such weapons. The USA has rushed an urgent supplyn of such weapons to Israel and they are being deployed against civilians. In Beirut Hospital the emergency services are running on generators and there is no supply of oxygen or medicines. Diabetic patients have run out of insulin and several have died in the last few weeks. The civic infrastructure has been completely and thoroughly destroyed.

The Israeli claim that they target civilian areas because they protect the Hizbollah and are launching ground for Katusha Rockets is to say the least an alibi. This is only a justification for large scale boming and causing civilian deaths as reparisals. Israel has not produced a shred of evidence to back this claim. The "embedded" American journalists who are keen to toe the line of their governemnt have visited the sites bombed by the Israelis and have clearly shown that they were only residential areas. No weapon, let alone rocket launchers have been found in the ruins of the bombed out buildings. It is an Orwellian tactic first pioneered by Dr Goebels: Repeat a lie a hundred times and people will start believing it. The cityscape of Souther Beirut, is packed with narrow lanes and by lanes with many high rise building, buit after the 74 civil war. It is impossible to fire rockets from such packed residential areas and Israel is using this to cover the warcimes it is commiting in Lebanon.

The capture of the 2 Israli soldiers by Hizbollah is generally trotted out as the cause for the outbreak of this round of hostilities. Even here the Israelis are being highly economical with truth. On July 29,1989 Israli commandos invaded the Lebonese toen of Jibchit and took Shiekh Abdul Karim captive in order to use him as a bargaining chip for excahning with some prisoners held by Hizbollah. UN Resolution 638 was of course ignored. In May 1994 Mustafe al-Dirani was kidnapped and brought to Israel, an act of what the Bushmen will call "Extraordinary rendition". He was held as an hostage inorder to be exchanged for the Israeli aviator Ron Arad who was shot down over Sidon in 1986. I can give more ibnstances but will stop at two just to prove that Israelis have gone in for prisoner exchanges in the past and while Hizbollah's actions were wrong, they were hardly the ones who begann this practice of taking prisoners for hostage and holding them on cAMPM 1391.

Even if we admit that Hizbollah did a morally reprehensible and politically irresponsible act, the reparisals launched by Israel have far far outweighed the intial act. Killing civilains on an industrial scale usinmg air power shows that Israel is now a state waging war against humanity and the International Community must act in adecicive manner to protect the lives of innocent men, women and children of Lebanon. Lebanon des not even have anti aircraft guns and to that extent the country has been demilitarise. In fact by its brutal, barbaric and savage actions against civilians Israel has forfeited whatever respect and synpathy it had.

What can the UN do. The UN was ineffective in Iraq and USA went ahead with its illegal war against Iraq and the world is seeing the consequences. UN resolutions 242, 338 and 638 have been ignored with US complicity while UN resolution 1559 is given the status of a biblical prophet. Moreover the negotiations within Lebanon for the implementatioinof this resolution had reached a criticasl stage when Istrael launched it barbaric campaign. The incantation form Israeli ministers that the Katusha Rockets are the cause of this action of reparisal. The fact is that more than 2000 Katusha Rockets have been fired and all of them have been firs from sites located away from the civilian areas. Israel is only using this to justify its callous disregard for the lives of Arab men women and children. It may not be out of place to note that the undercurrent of racism has always poisoned Arab-Israeli relations and by turning Lebanon into a 21st century killing field Israel has ceratinly lost whatever little respect it enjoyed in that part of theworld

Comments
on Jul 30, 2006
Once again you leave out or gloss over important details in the story. Like the fact that an endless barrage of missiles was being launched on Israel from the town, missiles packed with ball-bearings the purpose of which was to cause as much carnage as possible to Israeli civilians. Dismissing these important details out of hand and only presenting the parts of the story that bolster your argument is an ingenuous tactic.

If Hezbollah is going to target Israeli civilians and continue to hide their missile launchers within the Lebanese civilian population, then Lebanese civilians will continue to be killed. But make no mistake, the blame lies totally with Hezbollah for their disgusting practices.
on Jul 30, 2006
Gee, I guess gettin what you want by means of terrorism isn't what it's all cracked up to be, is it?
on Jul 30, 2006
There surely is terrorism in Gaza, Israel and Lebanon. Both Israel and the Moslem groups are the perpetrators! The United States is facilitating the process by supplying the Arms and standing by and refusing to join the other world leaders to demand an END to the DEATH and DISTRUCTION! Must be that Fundamentalist Christian Ethic at work!
on Jul 30, 2006
Sorry Bahu, but I expect better from you.  Your hatred of Israel is plain, at least you could present the facts correctly.  being a mouthpiece for Hezbollah does not become you.  I agree with UBob.
on Jul 30, 2006
On the video they showed earlier, it looked suspiciously like a truck parking, then firing missiles from that building. You can fire those rockets from the same kind of truck that people in residential areas use to haul lawn equipment. You could easily fire them from my driveway. So, you'd have to say the line:

"It is impossible to fire rockets from such packed residential areas and Israel is using this to cover the warcimes it is commiting in Lebanon."


...is an total, intolerable lie. People like to wash their lies in the blood of children because it makes them more politically palatable. Nothing to me is more shameful than covering the work of terrorists with dead innocents. This sort of thing, I hope, is beneath you, though I am beginning to wonder.
on Jul 31, 2006
Early this morning around 12:30 Israeli F-16 jets dropped bombs on the southern Lebonese city of Qana. In this attack a building housing refugees who had fled from earlier Israeli bombardment were targetted and the men, women and children sleeping in the basement of the building were killed when the Israeli bombs demolished the building.


I believe the building fell around 8 AM. The attack took place, as you say, sometime between 12:00-1:00 AM. While an easy link crosses the bombing and the collapse, 7 hours is plenty of time to evacuate the building. Nobody may have realized it would fall, but you can hardly charge Israel with "demolish[ing] the building...[while] men, women and children [were] sleeping in the basement."

Over 150 rockets were fired from the city, and there is video evidence of rockets being fired from the building or surrounding area.

Again, I have trouble with exorbitant claims of wanton destruction when the casualty figures are in reality extremely low.
on Jul 31, 2006
If Hezbollah is going to target Israeli civilians and continue to hide their missile launchers within the Lebanese civilian population, then Lebanese civilians will continue to be killed. But make no mistake, the blame lies totally with Hezbollah for their disgusting practices


Your hatred of Israel is plain, at least you could present the facts correctly. being a mouthpiece for Hezbollah does not become you.


People like to wash their lies in the blood of children because it makes them more politically palatable. Nothing to me is more shameful than covering the work of terrorists with dead innocents


Over 150 rockets were fired from the city, and there is video evidence of rockets being fired from the building or surrounding area.


I will begin by addressing the issue the Israeli allegation that Hizbollah is/has been using civilian areas for launching its Katusha Rockets. There are two related arguments at work here. If the claim that Hizbollah has indeed used civilian areas to launch rockets into Haifa and other cities than the frezied, genocidal rage of Israel is justified. Even if the Hizbollah has used civilian areas, Israel can only target the exact launch site not the entire city and lay it flat. Gartuitous destruction is hardly the work of soldiers: only vandals kill civilans. There is absolutely no moral equivalence between the Hizbollah and the IDF. The spokesperson of the Hizbollah has denied this accusation several time. Furthermore with western journalists crawling all over Beirut and Southern Lebanon and with the easy availibility of cell phone cameras and digital technology, it would be impossible for such an act to be covered up and hidden. The argument that civilian areas are being used for hiding and launching rockets has the same level of credibility as Holocaust Denial. It is highly depolorable that this unfounded and baseless allegation trumped up by the Israeli and the US Establishent has become the justification for the most brutal and criminal acts of repraiosals against Lebones civilians. Unfounded allegations are not proof. The Lebonese Governemnt has asked for an International Inquiry into this matter and the truth when it comes before the World hopefully will result in war crmes trials against the leaders of Israel and Hizbullah if indeed they have used civilians as cover.

Baker Street: I have seen the same grainy images put out by the Israli Foreign Office and trotted out as "PROOF' of Rocket Attack from Qana. This was done after the UN has deplored the barbaric act of Israel in bombing 64 women and children who were themselves refugees. Now USA has a whole array of spy sattelies all over the region and so do a host of other countries. With the kind of 1m by 1m resolution that is now available it is, and I emphasise impossible for the lauinch of Rockets not to be detected. This is only a post fact justification for a criminal act of state terrorism, and I am sorry that it has not been condemned.

I am not jewhater as you call. In fact I have a great deal of admiration for Israel and the no nonsense manner in which it handles Terrorism. I disagree on its brutal methods and it must be said that by such henous acts the resolution of peace is even more difficult. I think ideological loyalty should not make one blind to reality. As for Hizbullah they can drown in the Mediterranean for all I care. I do care for the lives of ordinary civilians and children.

What happened at Qana is a war crime and kindly do not trivalise such tragedies by ignoring the facts the circumstances and above all the truth.

on Jul 31, 2006
believe the building fell around 8 AM


There is something known as time difference in the world.
on Jul 31, 2006
If you want to believe that, fine, Bahu, but there was nothing grainy about the images in question. I coudl plainly see a motorcycle leading the truck there, and the missiles being fired shortly thereafter. Satellites have to be tasked to look at a small area as you describe, and I would find it much more suspicious a coincidence if the US had a satellite focused on that particular building for no reason.

I challenge you to prove that a rocket couldn't have been fired there as you assert in your blog. These aren't nearly as large as scuds, and scuds can be launched from populated areas. These launchers aren't much bigger than the larger U-Hauls we used to rent to pull behind a truck when we moved. As far as I am concerned if it fits in my driveway or along my sidewalk, it is certainly possible to launch from populated areas.

I never called you a jewhater, not the first time, please feel free to point out where I did. I do think, however, that you've slipped once again to a level of rhetoric where you'll purposely exaggerate and make claims the way you did about the rockets. I think, even when it is an emotional subject like this, such is beneath you and detracts from your argument.

To me it seems plain that Hezbollah was taking a beating, and knew that such a massacre had saved them ten years before. I think they engineered just such another massacre, knowing full well those people were in that building.
on Jul 31, 2006
There is something known as time difference in the world.


Your patronizing tone is unnecessary and rude. I know perfectly well there are differences in time worldwide. The building was struck, or nearly so, around 1 AM local time, and reported collapsing closer to 8 AM local time. This does not preclude an earlier fall, but people did vacate the building to check damage prior to the event.
on Jul 31, 2006
Patronizing & melodramatic. Pretty much sums him up.
on Aug 01, 2006
Your patronizing tone is unnecessary and rude


Curious Gee, I agree. It was rude, but the subject was too deep to permit, as I usually do, a politie answer. My apologies.
on Aug 01, 2006
Satellites have to be tasked to look at a small area as you describe, and I would find it much more suspicious a coincidence if the US had a satellite focused on that particular building for no reason.


BakerStreet:
The point is that the images are from the Israeli Government sources. You may have by now known that the images first published by the IDF purpotedly showing the firing of rockets from Qana taken from the tailcamera of a F-16 jet is now confirmed to be not of that place. When such henous crimes are committed in the name of fighting terrorism we have to be cartain that civilian areas are indeed being used to fire katyusha rockets. My point is that there is no proof, independent verifiable and authentic, and the Lebonon Governemnt has asked for an International inquitry.

I am also pointing out that this is not the first time that Israel has comitted its war crimes in Qana. I am sure you are aware that in 1992 100 civilians were killed by an unprooked Israeli attack.

I am sure the USA has satellites over the region afterall Iraq and other hotspots are not far.

The ref. to jewhater is to me by some other blogger not you.
on Aug 01, 2006
"My point is that there is no proof, independent verifiable and authentic, and the Lebonon Governemnt has asked for an International inquitry. "


And how could there be. Shall we allow the UN to act as a stalking horse, finding Hezbollah launch sites, visiting them with peacekeepers, clearing the buildings with inspectors, and then allowing Israel to fire on them? I find it curious that anyone would EXPECT for there to be independantly verifiable proof.

As I said, had the US happened to have a satellite pointed at that building you'd be right here claiming what a huge coincidence that was. Do you really believe that anyone would see a US satellite as "independent"?

"I am also pointing out that this is not the first time that Israel has comitted its war crimes in Qana. I am sure you are aware that in 1992 100 civilians were killed by an unprooked Israeli attack."


You could also point out that this isn't the first time Hezbollah scored a PR victory by baiting Israel into killing innocent people in Qana. You COULD be blaming the aggressor, instead of the nation defending itself. You pretend that Israel would have been doing this if Hezbollah hadn't attacked them on their own soil first.

Hezbollah has the power to end this conflict in mere minutes. Will they? Or will they continue to risk the lives of the Lebanese for their Iranian taskmasters? The idea that they are protecting anyone from Israel is a joke, Bahu, and I challenge you to make that argument.
on Aug 01, 2006
Here is the way that Bahu, OG San, and Col Sanders, and many of the others on this board that are so against Israel, but so for terrorists, would have this ended:

Israel surrenders...and retreats. Israel signs an agreement with the innocent terrorists, that will allow them to step into Israel at any time, to kidnap no more than 500 Israelis (civilians or soldiers, it doesn't matter). Now, these 500 Israelis are not comulative, but instead, can only be counted under the same kidnapping.

Israel will not be able to defend herself, but rather, must disarm. Israel will also cede it's national borders to Palestine, and Hizbollah....

Israel will be permitted to live within these other nations, but, will need to ask persmission from the terrorist organizations if it is ok for them to follow their religious practices.

If at any time, Israel decides to try to defend themselves, the UN will be posted nearby, making sure that the only weapons that Israel uses is desert dust (not even rocks are allowed). Also, Israel must allow a period of 6 weeks before attacking anywhere. During this 6 week period of time, they must send leaflets, and transport any who wish to leave the area. And, once the 6 week period is finished, they still must seek permission from the Hamas and/or Hizbollah before they strike.

blah blah blah blah blah...and the insanity goes on....Col Sanders, I am amazed that you do not hold the value of a soldiers life as citical...well, actually, you are a liberal "peace at all cost" nutcase, so, it doesn't amaze me. I just feel sorry for anyone who ever served under your sorry excuse for leadership.

Bahu...you are so full of this "peace at all cost" garbage, but it doesn't surprise me...not in the least. All of you "Peace at all Cost" just do not seem to realize, that war is a necesarry part of life when dealing with nutcases like Hamas, Al-Quada, Hizbollah....and you. You would rather we sit and be disected by the cockroaches that are terrorists, rather than bomb the living f*** out of them until they either have no more will to fight, or there just simply isn't any left to fight.

Col Sanders, you wanna know why we, the US is losing in these wars? Because we are not willing (nor are we able, due to the idiocy in the world) to take away their will to fight. I know that if we bombed the s*** out of them....I know that they would not continue...their will would be broken, or there just wouldn't be anymore left.

War is UGLY...and it should stay ugly. We should make it ugly, that way war will only happen when it cannot be avoided or ignored (Hitler, anyone?). Instead, Sanders, Bahu, OG San, and all the others (the "Peace at all Cost" group) wants war to be a nice walk in a flower garden....

Wake up, and realize that War is Raw, unadulterated, bloodbaths....and rightfully so, lest we fall in love with the idea of war.

To end it...blow the hell out of our enemies....without discrimination...and with the intent to kill, disable, and remove whatever threat we percieve to be in front of us. Because I know that is how THEY look at it.

Chris