World War II and its Meaning for the present
Nearly 60 years ago, a President of the American Historical Association, Carl Becker said famously:Everyman his own historian. What he meant was that each human being understands the events surrounding his life from his/her individual perspective. The victim remembers an incident differently from the pertetrator. Hence historical memory is the stuff life and civilization is made of, and we must not tamper with History just to make a rhetorical point or two. Granted that there can be different versions of the same event. What is not possible to accept is that events that have been understood and interpreted in a manner that conforms broadly to a social consensus of lived expeience, can be completely thrown away.
George Bush has done just that. He has appropriated the history of World War II entirely for the USA. In his version of the history of World War II, the contribution of the USSR does not amount to anything because the war was faught not to rid Europe of the monstriocity called German Nazism, but for Freedom and Democracy. In short Bush has outdid Churchill {in his notorious Fulton speech} by completely writing Russia out of the historical record. Of course, he joined in the 60 th Year Celebrations of the end of the war, but he did it in such a graceless manner. His speech, probably the worst in his entire life,was that of a neo con politician not that of a statesman using the pulpit provided by a glorious moment in history, to tarnish the historical record and score debating points of an extremely dubious kind.
The USA entered the War against Japan only after Pearl Habor in December 1941.A day that will live in INFAMY as Roosevelt declared. Only in June of 1944 did American troops land in Europe. American troops faught hard and 800,000 men died in Europe to free the continent from German tyranny. Any country can be proud of history such as that. The facts of History, however, are that the erstwhile USSR faught Germany single handed from 1942 to 44 and had liberated Poland and Eastern Germany by the time the US troops arrived in Berlin. It would be extremely wrong to say that Soviet War Effort did not contributre much to the eventual defeat of German Nazism. The Yalta Agreement stemmed from the realization that the security of the World can only be done through a collective effort. American unilateralism is undermining that important effect of the war and Bush is now trying to rewrite history by saying that the Yalta Conference was an error. Without Yalta the peace in Europe could not have been maintained.
In his desire to wave the flag of Unilateralism, Bush is seeking to reinterpret the History of World War II. Remember 30 million Russians died and they faught virtually alone. Stalingrad was the turning point ogf the war.